Project ideas and requirements often arise before they become concrete projects. A central idea pool helps to capture ideas in a structured way, evaluate them according to consistent criteria, and make the subsequent decision-making process transparent.
This makes it easier to compare different ideas and systematically follow them up before an idea becomes a concrete project.
Capture project ideas centrally
To collect project ideas centrally, a dedicated project such as Ideen-Pool can be created in smenso. Within a common folder such as Ideensammlung, each idea is recorded as a separate task.
The task title should describe the idea as clearly as possible. Additional information about the background, expected benefits, or objective of the idea can be recorded in the description.
Additional Flavors can be used for a consistent evaluation, for example:
Bereich– to assign the idea to a business or topic area.Nutzen– for a rough assessment of the expected benefits.Umsetzungsaufwand– for an initial estimate of the required effort, for example usingS,M,L, orXL.Strategische Relevanz– for example, to classify the idea asOperativ,Taktisch, orStrategisch.
Evaluate and compare ideas
In the List view, the collected ideas can be displayed together and compared based on the defined criteria. Relevant Flavors such as Bereich, Nutzen, Umsetzungsaufwand, and Strategische Relevanz can be displayed as columns.
The current status can also be displayed. This makes it easy to see which ideas are still being evaluated, are ready for a decision, or have already been accepted, put on hold, or rejected.
Track ideas throughout the decision-making process
A dedicated workflow can be used to structure the evaluation and decision-making process for ideas. A possible Ideenmanagement workflow could include the following statuses:
Eingereicht → In Bewertung → Zur Entscheidung → Angenommen / Zurückgestellt / Abgelehnt
In the Board view, ideas can be grouped by Status (Workflows). This makes it easy to see which stage of the decision-making process each idea is currently in.
Turn an idea into a project
Once an idea has been accepted, it can serve as the basis for a concrete project. The idea is then transferred from the early evaluation and decision-making phase into further project planning.
In the new project, aspects such as scope, dates, responsibilities, effort, and other project details can then be defined in more detail. The idea pool remains available as an overview of submitted, accepted, postponed, and rejected ideas.
Idea pool in the video
The following video shows an example of a separate idea pool in smenso in which project ideas are captured using Microsoft Forms.
Best Practice
An idea pool should be kept as simple as possible so that new ideas can be captured quickly and then evaluated according to consistent criteria.
- Clearly separate the early idea phase from concrete project planning.
- Capture each idea according to a consistent structure so that different proposals remain comparable.
- Use a small number of meaningful evaluation criteria such as benefits, implementation effort, and strategic relevance.
- Use a workflow to make the evaluation and decision-making process transparent.
- Review ideas that have been put on hold regularly, as conditions and priorities may change.
- Transfer accepted ideas into concrete project planning only after they have been approved.
Comments
0 comments
Please sign in to leave a comment.